J_Scarbrough wrote:
A non-American friend and I were having a discussion the other day, but I think it would be interesting to share this particular thought of mine here as well, since it seems like the majority of this community is non-American as well.
…
Haven't counted how many here are American and how many aren't, but we're pretty international indeed.
Anyway, if you want another non-American perspective, allow me to add the following.
Like probably most people in my vicinity, I don't think it's not that much about the campaigning, because that has long been degenerating into pretty much the same kind of mudslinging over here.
Us Germans usually don't get about American campaigning that the focus is much more on the candidates as persons and how they come across (although how that famous smug grin of Trump's can make anyone not want to punch him is a bit beyond me). We don't vote for a chancellor, although these candidates are fixed before the elections and make the bulk of public appearances, but for parties.
And there's another thing many of us have a hard time of getting our head around. If you directly compare the political spectrum of both countries, according to party lines, you'll get something like this:
Democrats = CDU/CSU (“conservative” which however in the US would translate as liberal with just a slight touch of occasional conservatism), FDP (liberal, economy-focused), SPD (social democrats in the same tradition as the British Labour Party), Grüne (Greens: left-wing, ecologist), some of the more moderate members of Die Linke (generally very left-wing, successor to the GDR's communist party but largely ignoring that part of their history)
Republicans = AfD (right-wing populist party, Russia-friendly, under observation by the domestic intelligence service because of quite a few members pushing their right-wing tendencies way too far), some parts of the CSU (conservative, only active in Bavaria in place of the CDU with whom they form a parliamentary group on a national level; it's all a bit complicated)
Basically, 80-90% of seats in our parliament would be taken by Democrats (I'm trying to account for variations within our parties in this estimate) and to most here this still means an alarmingly high number of seats taken by the right, while the differences between the parties are considered so large by each of them that they almost always make forming a governing coalition a nerve-wracking, fickle procedure with a result nobody is really happy with. That our current coalition has just announced an early election, having fallen apart due to its inner struggles that just paralysed everything, is actually a relief to many, of all political colours.
The really interesting thing to consider here is that the Democrats somehow seem to manage to keep almost as many different political leanings together, nonetheless, when they're sworn enemies here. Quite a fascinating feat, really.
Now, I don't want to suggest for a moment Americans are generally more right-leaning - that wouldn't just be a gross oversimplification but also plain wrong - but that could only mean that party lines play less of a role in elections, and that the actual political spectrum is kind of misrepresented in one of our countries or, more likely, both. Of course, they'll never be quite comparable, because our “conservative” is very different from what Americans would call “conservative”. You couldn't even say that one is necessarily more right-leaning than the other, because they focus on very different things.
People tend to ignore all that when making comparisons, though, which may lead to misunderstandings.
Incidentally, talking about isolating oneself in little rose-coloured filter bubbles quite disconnected from reality, I sometimes get the impression that that's pretty evenly spread across about the entire party spectrum over here, although the closer you look at both of its ends the worse it arguably gets.
Last but not least, what confuses us here is the “winner takes all” approach and the electoral college. Why this is still kept up is probably the one question e.g. my students in English classes ask me most. But then, from what I gather, many Americans seem to wonder about that, too.